Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria

898 Barber St, Athens, GA 30601

Café / Breakfast

License: Food Service

Last inspected: Dec 29, 2025

Score

Low Risk

Going back to 2024, Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria has four inspections in the public record. Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria was last inspected on Dec 29, 2025. Low risk indicates the latest report didn't flag anything that would worry the average customer.

There hasn't been much movement either way: counts have stayed near two violations per visit across recent inspections.

The most common issue across all inspections has been “plumbing installed”, showing up four times.

The city-wide average is 88, putting Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria squarely in typical territory. There isn't much in the file that would give a customer pause.

Inspections

Critical latest

Major latest

Minor latest

Inspection History

Dec 29, 2025

Routine

2 minor violations.

View 2 violations

11D - thermometers provided and accurate

Inspector notes: No thermometers in reach-in coolers.

511-6-1.05(2)(x)

16B - plumbing installed; proper backflow devices

Inspector notes: Prep sink leaking at faucet.

511-6-1.06(2)(r)

Jun 16, 2025

Routine

4 minor violations.

View 4 violations

15A - food and nonfood-contact surfaces cleanable, properly designed, constructed, and used

Inspector notes: Cutting board on cutting board rack heavily marked.

511-6-1.05(6)(b)

15A - food and nonfood-contact surfaces cleanable, properly designed, constructed, and used

Inspector notes: Observed reach-in freezer on food line leaking.

511-6-1.05(6)(a)

16B - plumbing installed; proper backflow devices

Inspector notes: Observed prep sink in kitchen leaking at faucet.

511-6-1.06(2)(r)

18 - insects, rodents, and animals not present

Inspector notes: Observed live roach in between reach-in coolers in kitchen.

511-6-1.07(5)(k)

Dec 17, 2024

Routine

1 major violation. 1 minor violation.

View 2 violations

2-2D - adequate handwashing facilities supplied & accessible

Inspector notes: No paper towels at main kitchen hand wash sink. Corrective action (CA): All handwashing sinks must be supplied with paper towels.

511-6-1.07(3)(b)

16B - plumbing installed; proper backflow devices

Inspector notes: 3-compartment sink and prep sink leaking at faucet.

511-6-1.06(2)(r)

Apr 24, 2024

Routine

1 critical violation. 2 minor violations. 1 corrected on site.

View 3 violations

10D - food properly labeled; original container (corrected on site)

Inspector notes: Multiple yogurt and one sour cream container expired a week ago. Items discarded.

511-6-1.04(8)(b)

14B - utensils, equipment and linens: properly stored, dried, handled

Inspector notes: Multiple metal bins stacked wet on clean dish rack. Allow to fully air-dry before stacking.

511-6-1.05(10)(e)

16B - plumbing installed; proper backflow devices

Inspector notes: 3-compartment sink and prep sink have leaky faucet.

511-6-1.06(2)(r)

Frequently Asked Questions

When was Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria last inspected?

The most recent health inspection at Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria on file is from Dec 29, 2025. The public record contains four inspections in total.

What is the most common violation at Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria?

Across the inspection record, “plumbing installed” has been cited four times, more than any other issue at Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria.

How does Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria compare to other restaurants in Athens?

Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria most recently scored 90 out of 100, which is about the same as the Athens average of 88.

Has Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria's inspection record improved over time?

Results have been roughly steady. Inspections at Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria have averaged around two violations per visit across the recent record.

What does a low risk rating mean?

A low risk rating at Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria means inspectors found minimal or no significant issues at the most recent visit. Most facilities at this tier have a clean recent inspection report.

How often is Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria inspected?

Based on the inspection history on file, Five Star Pilgrims Kill Cafeteria is inspected around two times per year on average.

Nearby Restaurants

Allgood Lounge

256 E Clayton St

Score: 82 — Low Risk

The Rialto Room at the Hotel Indigo

500 College Ave

Score: 90 — Low Risk

Up Dawg

400 E Clayton St Ste A

Score: 95 — Low Risk

Explore More

→ All locations in Athens → Café / Breakfast restaurants in Georgia → Café / Breakfast restaurants in Athens