Mystic Lobster Roll Company

1035 N Collier Blvd #310, Marco Island, FL 34145

Seafood

Last inspected: Dec 1, 2025

Score

Low Risk

Inspectors have visited Mystic Lobster Roll Company three times, with records going back to 2024. The newest entry in the record is dated Dec 1, 2025. A low risk rating suggests inspectors haven't found much to be concerned about lately.

Violation counts have been trending down, averaging around one violation across recent inspections versus roughly six violations before.

The pattern that stands out is “no chemical test kit provided when using sanitizer”, which has been cited two times.

Among Marco Island restaurants, the typical score is 76; Mystic Lobster Roll Company is comfortably above that bar. Overall, the inspection record reads well.

Inspections

Critical latest

Major latest

Minor latest

Inspection History

Dec 1, 2025

Food-Licensing Inspection

1 major violation.

View 1 violation

Potentially Hazardous Food Held at Proper Temperature

FL-16

Oct 17, 2024

Routine - Food

1 critical violation. 3 major violations. 4 minor violations.

View 8 violations

High Priority - Toxic substance/chemical improperly stored. There are containers of hand soap stored with and above containers of sugar. Operator moved the soap to proper storage. **Corrected On-Site** **Warning**

41-10-4

Intermediate - Handwash sink used for purposes other than handwashing. There is a stainless steel scrubber in the hand washing sink next to the triple sink. **Warning**

31A-11-4

Intermediate - No chemical test kit provided when using sanitizer at three-compartment sink/warewashing machine or wiping cloths. There is no test kit for chlorine sanitizer. **Warning**

16-37-1

Intermediate - No proof of required state approved employee training provided for any employees. To order approved program food safety material, call DBPR contracted provider: Florida Restaurant and Lodging Association (SafeStaff) 866-372-7233. **Warning**

53B-01-5

Basic - Working containers of food removed from original container not identified by common name. There are multiple unlabeled containers of sugar in the kitchen. **Warning**

02D-01-5

Basic - Employee personal food not properly identified and segregated from food to be served to the public. In the upright cooler there is a to go box of partially eaten employee food not marked or segregated from food to be served to the public. **Warning**

08B-49-4

Basic - Reuse of single-service or single-use articles. There are multiple single use coleslaw containers used to hold sugar. **Warning**

25-32-4

Basic - Time/temperature control for safety food thawed in an improper manner. There are bags of cooked lobster thawing in standing water in the triple sink. **Warning**

06-01-5

Jun 27, 2024

Food-Licensing Inspection

1 major violation. 2 minor violations.

View 3 violations

Intermediate - No chemical test kit provided when using sanitizer at three-compartment sink/warewashing machine or wiping cloths.

16-37-1

Basic - No handwashing sign provided at a hand sink used by food employees. There are no hand washing signs at either hand washing sink. Operator provided with hand washing signs. **Corrective Action Taken**

31B-04-4

Basic - Bathroom located inside establishment not completely enclosed with tight-fitting, self-closing doors.

32-04-4

Frequently Asked Questions

When was Mystic Lobster Roll Company last inspected?

The most recent health inspection at Mystic Lobster Roll Company on file is from Dec 1, 2025. The public record contains three inspections in total.

What is the most common violation at Mystic Lobster Roll Company?

Across the inspection record, “no chemical test kit provided when using sanitizer” has been cited two times, more than any other issue at Mystic Lobster Roll Company.

How does Mystic Lobster Roll Company compare to other restaurants in Marco Island?

Mystic Lobster Roll Company most recently scored 90 out of 100, which is higher than the Marco Island average of 76.

Has Mystic Lobster Roll Company's inspection record improved over time?

Yes. Recent inspections at Mystic Lobster Roll Company have averaged around one violation per visit, down from roughly six earlier in the record.

What does a low risk rating mean?

A low risk rating at Mystic Lobster Roll Company means inspectors found minimal or no significant issues at the most recent visit. Most facilities at this tier have a clean recent inspection report.

Nearby Restaurants

599 S Collier Boulevard #215-217

Score: 82 — Low Risk

The Oyster Society

599 S Collier Blvd #218

Score: 74 — Medium Risk

Explore More

→ All locations in Marco Island → Seafood restaurants in Florida → Seafood restaurants in Marco Island